Observing Your Thoughts: An Introductory Meditation Practice
In previous articles, we've explored our relationship with thoughts, the difficulty of recognizing them for what they are, and the difference between understanding something and actually experiencing it.
But understanding how the mind works isn't the same as getting to know it through direct experience.
We can spend a great deal of time reading about our thoughts, reflecting on them, and discussing them. Yet we rarely stop to observe them without trying to change, interpret, or follow them.
I'd like to introduce a simple meditation practice that requires no special knowledge and offers anyone a place to begin.
Where This Practice Comes From
The following exercise comes from the first stage of mental training described by Franz Bardon in Initiation into Hermetics, originally published in 1956.
Bardon presents it as the opening exercise in a much broader system of Hermetic training. His instructions were later explored and clarified by Rawn Clark in A Bardon Companion.
Here, we'll focus on this first exercise alone, explaining it in a way that makes it accessible even to readers who have no particular interest in Hermeticism.
You don't need to share Bardon's philosophical outlook or follow his complete system to explore the practice of observing your thoughts.
If you'd like to learn more about its original context, you'll find references at the end of this article.
What Is the Purpose of This Exercise?
The purpose of this practice is to understand how your own mind works through direct experience, gradually developing the ability to observe thoughts without becoming caught up in them.
During meditation, however, your task is simply to observe.
Throughout the day, we recall past events, imagine future situations, replay conversations, make judgments, and work through problems. We're often so absorbed in this activity that we hardly notice how easily our attention gets carried away.
One memory can lead to another. A worry can turn into a long, imaginary conversation. We may find ourselves reliving something that happened years ago, without even noticing how we got there.
Through this exercise, we begin to become familiar with the mind's natural activity, learning to recognize the difference between noticing a thought and getting drawn into it.
We're not trying to eliminate thoughts. Thinking is a natural activity of the mind.
We're learning to observe thoughts without necessarily having to follow them.
Over time, this ability may also prove useful beyond meditation, especially when we find ourselves caught up in worries, judgments, or our reactions to everyday situations.
How to Practice
Find a quiet place where you're unlikely to be disturbed for a few minutes.
Sit comfortably in a chair or armchair. You can also lie down if you prefer, as long as you're unlikely to fall asleep.
There's no need to adopt a particular posture. Allow your body to relax while remaining alert and attentive.
Close your eyes.
Now simply turn your attention toward what's happening in your mind.
Observe the thoughts that arise.
They might concern something that happened earlier in the day, a problem you need to solve, a conversation you had with someone, or what you're planning to do tomorrow.
Images, memories, words, or seemingly unrelated fragments of thought may appear.
It doesn't matter.
Don't try to choose which thoughts to observe. Don't attempt to stop them, change them, or replace them with more pleasant ones.
Don't try to slow them down, either.
Let your mind go about its usual activity, and simply observe.
Observing thoughts is a little like sitting on a park bench and watching people walk past.
Some move slowly, others quickly. Someone might catch your attention more than the others.
You can watch them pass without getting up to follow them.
In much the same way, you can observe thoughts without feeling compelled to become involved in the stories they tell.
Especially at first, you'll probably notice that you've become caught up in your thinking.
Perhaps one thought led to a memory, that memory to a worry, and before you knew it, you'd spent several minutes completely absorbed in an unfolding story.
When you notice this, simply return to observing.
There's no need to reconstruct the chain of thoughts that brought you there. Don't criticize yourself or try to make up for the time you spent distracted.
Just resume observing from where you are.
You may also find that, as you observe, thoughts become less frequent or temporarily disappear.
Don't try to maintain that state. But don't attempt to make thoughts appear again, either.
Whether thoughts are frequent, occasional, or temporarily absent, remain attentive without trying to change what is happening.
To begin with, spend about five minutes on this practice.
As you become more familiar with the exercise, you can gradually increase the duration to ten minutes.
Bardon recommends practicing in the morning and evening. You can use this as a guideline, adapting it to your own schedule and circumstances.
Regular practice matters, but there's no need to turn it into another source of pressure or frustration.
The goal isn't to spend ten minutes without thinking. It's to learn to observe mental activity without being constantly swept along by it.
Some Questions That May Arise
An exercise that seems so simple can raise a surprising number of questions, especially when you're just starting out.
The following questions address some of the most common difficulties.
It's important, however, not to try to answer these questions while meditating.
During the exercise, your only task is to observe. You don't need to analyze what's happening, search for explanations, or constantly evaluate how well you're doing.
If a question spontaneously arises in your mind, you can observe it just like any other thought. There's no need to suppress it, but there's also no need to pursue an answer.
Reflection and evaluation can wait until after the session.
Question: If I get lost in my thoughts, does that mean I'm doing something wrong?
Answer: Not necessarily. Getting caught up in thoughts is something that happens, especially in the beginning. What matters is recognizing when it happens and returning to observation. With practice, you may find yourself noticing more quickly when a thought has captured your attention.
Question: Do I need to remember all the thoughts that appeared during the exercise?
Answer: No. This isn't a memory exercise, and you don't need to keep a mental record of everything you've thought about. The aim is to remain aware of thoughts as they arise, not to remember them afterward.
Question: What happens if my thoughts slow down or disappear?
Answer: You don't need to do anything in particular. Sometimes the flow of thoughts naturally slows when it's observed without involvement. There's no need to try to preserve that state. In this exercise, we're not attempting to create mental silence. That is a different practice, introduced later in Bardon's system.
Question: What if I keep having lots of thoughts?
Answer: That's normal, too. Mental activity is constantly changing and can be influenced by many things: worries, tiredness, emotions, and the events of the day. Don't judge the success of your practice by how many thoughts arise. Even a particularly busy mind gives you something to observe.
Question: How can I tell whether I'm making progress?
Answer: Consider how well you're able to remain aware of what's happening in your mind without getting caught up in it. At first, you might lose yourself in thoughts frequently, only realizing what happened after quite some time. With practice, you may begin to recognize these moments sooner and maintain an observing attitude for longer periods. This ability, rather than the number of thoughts you experience, is one of the most useful signs of progress.
A Simple Practice to Deepen Over Time
You might find this exercise remarkably easy, or you might encounter difficulties you hadn't expected.
There's no need to draw conclusions after your first few sessions.
Something that seems obvious today may reveal different aspects of itself as time goes on.
Observing thoughts isn't a competition, nor is it an attempt to reach a particular mental state as quickly as possible.
It's a way of gradually becoming familiar with something that accompanies us throughout our lives, yet rarely receives this kind of attention.
Perhaps you'll notice how often thoughts follow one another without any clear direction. Or how easily a simple memory can capture your attention completely.
You might also begin to recognize that you don't have to engage with every thought that appears.
There's no need to deliberately seek out these discoveries.
Allow the experience itself to show you what there is to observe.
For now, five minutes is enough to begin.
Further Reading
This practice is an introductory adaptation of the first mental exercise presented by Franz Bardon. It is not intended as a complete description of his system of Hermetic training.
If you'd like to explore the original exercise, its interpretation, and the broader path of which it forms a part, the following works are useful starting points:
- Franz Bardon, Initiation into Hermetics (1956). Practical section, Step I, Mental Training.
- Rawn Clark, A Bardon Companion, Second Edition (2010). Commentary on Step One and the questions and answers concerning mental training.
Both works offer a broader perspective on the meaning of the exercise and its place within the Hermetic tradition.